Pass the IIA CIA IIA-CIA-Part3 Questions and answers with CertsForce

The chief audit executive (CAE) plays a crucial role in evaluating strategic decisions, including outsourcing IT functions. The most appropriate first step is to assess whether the proposal aligns with the organization's overall strategy and verify that the supporting information is reliable and complete before making further evaluations.

Strategic Alignment:

The CAE must first determine whether outsourcing supports the organization’s long-term objectives, risk tolerance, and business goals.

Reliability of Supporting Information:

Before evaluating costs, risks, or operational impacts, the CAE must ensure that management’s data and assumptions are accurate and complete.

IIA Standards on Governance and Risk Management:

IIA Standard 2110 - Governance requires auditors to evaluate decision-making processes, including outsourcing.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management emphasizes assessing risks associated with major decisions like outsourcing.

B. Ascertain whether governance and approval processes are transparent, documented, and completed:

While governance is important, this step comes after verifying strategic alignment.

C. Perform a due diligence review or assess management’s review of provider operations:

Due diligence is a later step in outsourcing evaluation, not the first priority.

D. Identify key performance measures and data sources:

Key performance measures are useful for monitoring outsourcing after approval, but they do not determine initial alignment with strategy.

IIA Standard 2110 - Governance: Requires internal auditors to evaluate whether key decisions align with organizational objectives.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management: Internal auditors must assess potential risks and verify the reliability of information used for decision-making.

COBIT Framework - IT Governance: Emphasizes strategic alignment of IT decisions, including outsourcing.

Key Reasons Why Option A is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is A. Understand strategic context and evaluate whether supporting information is reliable and complete.

In the context of big data governance, the responsibilities of various stakeholders are delineated as follows:

A. Management's Responsibilities:

Management holds the primary responsibility for establishing and maintaining effective data governance frameworks. This includes ensuring that information storage systems are appropriately defined and that processes for updating critical data elements are clear and well-documented. Such measures are essential to maintain data integrity, availability, and confidentiality. The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA) emphasizes that management is accountable for the design and implementation of data governance structures, policies, and procedures. These structures should encompass data storage solutions and the mechanisms for updating and managing critical data elements.

The Institute of Internal Auditors

B. External Auditors' Responsibilities:

External auditors are tasked with providing independent assurance on the effectiveness of an organization's financial reporting and related controls. While they may consider the implications of big data on financial reporting, their primary focus is not on the periodic monitoring and maintenance of analytical models. Instead, this responsibility typically falls under management or specialized internal functions. The IIA outlines that external auditors assess the overall control environment but do not directly manage or maintain analytical models.

C. The Board's Responsibilities:

The board of directors provides oversight and strategic direction for the organization's data governance initiatives. However, the implementation of specific controls around data quality dimensions is generally delegated to management. The board ensures that appropriate governance structures are in place and that management is effectively addressing data quality and governance issues. According to the IIA, the board's role is to oversee the data governance framework, ensuring that management has implemented effective controls and processes.

The Institute of Internal Auditors

D. Internal Auditors' Responsibilities:

Internal auditors provide independent assurance on the effectiveness of governance, risk management, and control processes, including those related to data quality and security. While they assess and report on the adequacy of controls over data, the responsibility for ensuring data quality and security rests with management. The IIA states that internal auditors evaluate the effectiveness of data governance practices but do not hold primary responsibility for data quality and security.

The Institute of Internal Auditors

In summary, option A accurately reflects management's responsibility in big data governance, aligning with the IIA's guidelines on data governance roles and responsibilities.

The direct write-off method records bad debts only when an account is deemed uncollectible, meaning there is no estimation of bad debts in advance. This method is typically used when bad debts are immaterial (insignificant) because it does not adhere to the matching principle of accounting.

Simplicity and Practicality:

The direct write-off method is straightforward and only requires writing off bad debts as they occur.

It is best suited for companies where bad debt losses are minimal or rare.

Acceptable for Insignificant Losses:

If bad debts are not material, then estimating and recording an allowance in advance (as in the allowance method) may not be necessary.

Used by Small Businesses and Tax Accounting:

The IRS allows the direct write-off method for tax purposes because it recognizes expenses only when they occur.

Not Aligned with GAAP for Significant Losses:

Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) prefer the allowance method, which estimates bad debts in advance to match expenses with related revenues.

B. It provides a better alignment with revenue:

Incorrect because the allowance method provides a better revenue-expense matching approach, not the direct write-off method.

C. It is the preferred method according to The IIA:

The IIA does not have a stated preference between the two methods; however, GAAP prefers the allowance method.

D. It states receivables at net realizable value on the balance sheet:

The allowance method states receivables at net realizable value (NRV) by estimating bad debts in advance, while the direct write-off method does not adjust receivables until a loss occurs.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management: Internal auditors must assess financial risks, including credit risks and bad debt write-offs.

COSO Internal Control Framework - Financial Reporting Component: Emphasizes accurate financial reporting, where the allowance method is generally preferred for better estimation.

Key Reasons Why Option A is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is A. It is useful when losses are considered insignificant.

To maximize profit with a limited material supply of 500 kg per month, the company should prioritize producing the product that generates the highest contribution margin per kg of material used.

Step 1: Calculate Contribution Margin Per Unit for Each ProductSince fixed costs are not relevant in this decision, we focus on the contribution margin per unit of raw material:

Selling price per unit = $10

Material cost per unit = 2 kg × $1/kg = $2

Contribution margin per unit = $10 - $2 = $8

Contribution margin per kg = $8 ÷ 2 kg = $4 per kg

Selling price per unit = $13

Material cost per unit = 6 kg × $1/kg = $6

Contribution margin per unit = $13 - $6 = $7

Contribution margin per kg = $7 ÷ 6 kg = $1.17 per kg

Product X ($4 per kg) is more profitable per kg than Product Y ($1.17 per kg).

To maximize profit, produce as many units of Product X as possible first, then allocate the remaining material to Product Y.

First, maximize production of Product X

Each unit of Product X requires 2 kg.

Maximum units of Product X = 500 kg ÷ 2 kg per unit = 250 units.

However, demand is only 70 units, so produce 70 units of Product X.

Material used for 70 units of X = 70 × 2 kg = 140 kg.

Material remaining = 500 kg - 140 kg = 360 kg.

Use remaining material for Product Y

Each unit of Product Y requires 6 kg.

Maximum units of Product Y = 360 kg ÷ 6 kg per unit = 60 units.

Produce 70 units of Product X (to meet demand).

Produce 60 units of Product Y (using the remaining material).

IIA GTAG 13: Business Performance Management – Discusses maximizing profit by prioritizing high contribution margin products.

IIA Practice Guide: Cost Analysis for Decision-Making – Covers constraints and resource allocation for maximizing profitability.

Product XProduct YStep 2: Prioritize Product with Higher Contribution Margin Per KgStep 3: Allocate Limited Material (500 kg)Final Decision:IIA References for Validation:Thus, B (60 units) is the correct answer because it optimally allocates the 500 kg of material to maximize profit.

Total Quality Management (TQM) focuses on continuous improvement, teamwork, and process efficiency. The CAE’s goal is to reduce audit time and improve client satisfaction, which requires collaborative decision-making and diverse skill sets to ensure a high-quality, efficient audit process.

(A) Assign a team with a trained audit manager to plan each audit and distribute fieldwork tasks to various staff auditors. ❌

Incorrect. While structured planning is beneficial, TQM emphasizes decentralized decision-making rather than relying solely on the audit manager.

(B) Assign a team of personnel who have different specialties to each audit and empower team members to participate fully in key decisions. ✅

Correct. TQM encourages cross-functional teams, collaboration, and shared decision-making, which helps in reducing audit time and improving quality.

IIA GTAG "Auditing Continuous Improvement Initiatives" highlights diverse audit teams as a best practice for improving audit effectiveness.

(C) Assign a team to each audit, designate a single person to be responsible for each phase of the audit, and limit decision-making outside of their area of responsibility. ❌

Incorrect. This approach is too rigid and limits team collaboration, which contradicts TQM principles.

(D) Assign a team of personnel who have similar specialties to specific engagements that would benefit from those specialties and limit key decisions to the senior person. ❌

Incorrect. Specializing teams in certain audits may improve technical accuracy, but TQM promotes diverse perspectives rather than restricting decisions to one senior auditor.

IIA GTAG – "Auditing Continuous Improvement Initiatives"

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance (Process Improvement)

ISO 9001 – Total Quality Management Principles

Analysis of Answer Choices:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is B, as TQM supports cross-functional teams and shared decision-making to improve audit efficiency and client satisfaction.

Integrity controls are application controls designed to monitor data being processed to ensure that it remains accurate, consistent, and valid throughout its lifecycle. These controls help detect and prevent data corruption, unauthorized modifications, and inconsistencies in transactional systems.

Integrity controls enforce data validation, consistency checks, and reconciliation procedures to prevent errors during processing.

Examples include checksum validation, referential integrity constraints, and automated reconciliations to ensure data accuracy.

The IIA’s Global Technology Audit Guide (GTAG) 8 – Auditing Application Controls highlights integrity controls as a key measure in maintaining data reliability.

A. Management trail controls → Incorrect. These refer to audit trails and logs that track changes and actions within a system but do not actively monitor or correct data integrity.

B. Output controls → Incorrect. These focus on ensuring final reports, documents, or processed data outputs are accurate but do not monitor data during processing.

D. Input controls → Incorrect. These verify the accuracy and completeness of data at the point of entry, but they do not continuously monitor data throughout processing.

IIA GTAG 8 – Auditing Application Controls recommends integrity controls to maintain data accuracy.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management states that internal auditors should assess data integrity risks in business processes.

ISACA’s COBIT Framework identifies data integrity as a key IT control objective.

Why Option C is Correct?Explanation of the Other Options:IIA References & Best Practices:Thus, the correct answer is C. Integrity controls.

Comprehensive and Detailed Step-by-Step Explanation with all IIA References:

Understanding Physical Security Controls:

Physical security controls are measures that protect physical assets from unauthorized access, theft, or damage.

These include locks, security cameras, guards, and restricted access areas.

Why Secured Servers with Locks is Correct:

Locking system servers ensures that only authorized personnel can physically access them, protecting data from theft or tampering.

This aligns with best practices in IT security by safeguarding critical infrastructure.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. Transaction logs → This is a logical security control, not a physical one.

B. Strong passwords and access controls → These are technical security controls, not physical.

C. Failed login attempt analysis → This is an audit/logging control, which helps detect incidents but does not physically protect assets.

IIA Standards and References:

IIA GTAG on Information Security (2016): Recommends physical access controls for IT assets.

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance: Ensures IT security includes physical protections.

NIST Cybersecurity Framework: Identifies physical access control as a key protection measure.

Thus, the correct answer is D: System servers are secured by locking mechanisms with access granted to specific individuals.

Understanding Capital Budgeting Techniques:

Capital budgeting helps organizations evaluate long-term investment decisions based on expected cash flows.

NPV (Net Present Value) considers total expected net cash flows over the investment’s life and discounts them to present value.

Why Option D (Net Present Value) Is Correct?

NPV calculates the present value of future net cash flows, adjusting for the time value of money.

If NPV is positive, the investment is considered profitable.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management emphasizes financial decision-making tools like NPV for evaluating investment risks.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect?

Option A (Cash Payback):

Measures time to recover initial investment but does not consider total net cash flows.

Option B (Annual Rate of Return):

Uses accounting income, not cash flows, and does not factor in the time value of money.

Option C (Incremental Analysis):

Compares alternative options but does not evaluate total cash flows from an investment.

NPV is the correct method as it evaluates total expected cash flows over time.

IIA Standard 2120 supports financial analysis in investment decision-making.

Final Justification:IIA References:

IPPF Standard 2120 – Risk Management (Capital Budgeting & Investment Risks)

COSO ERM – Financial Risk Management & Decision Analysis

Financial Management Best Practices – NPV Analysis

Understanding Predictive Analytics:

Predictive analytics involves using historical data, statistical algorithms, and machine learning techniques to forecast future trends and behaviors.

It applies assumptions and models patterns to predict outcomes, helping businesses make proactive decisions.

Why Option B is Correct:

Predictive analytics is forward-looking and uses assumptions (e.g., weather conditions) to predict where stock levels would decrease more quickly.

This aligns with the goal of predictive analytics: forecasting potential events before they occur.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. Analyzed instances where parts were out of stock before scheduled deliveries: This is descriptive analytics, as it looks at past data without making future predictions.

C. Analyzed past stockouts and found a correlation with stormy weather: This is diagnostic analytics, as it identifies past correlations but does not predict future trends.

D. Modeled different scenarios for stock reordering and delivery decisions: This is prescriptive analytics, which focuses on decision-making rather than predictions.

IIA Standards and References:

IIA GTAG on Data Analytics (2017): Highlights predictive analytics as a tool for forecasting risks and operational inefficiencies.

IIA Standard 1220 – Due Professional Care: Encourages auditors to use analytical techniques to anticipate potential issues.

COSO ERM Framework: Supports the use of predictive models to improve risk management and strategic planning.

Thus, the correct answer is B: A supplier of electrical parts analyzed sales, applied assumptions related to weather conditions, and identified locations where stock levels would decrease more quickly.

Definition of Flexible Budgets:

Flexible budgeting allows organizations to adjust budgeted expenses based on actual performance levels.

Unlike static budgets, flexible budgets provide different financial projections for varying levels of activity.

Why Flexible Budgets are Useful:

They adjust for actual business conditions, making them useful in planning and cost control.

Organizations can compare actual results against the appropriate budget level rather than a single static budget.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect:

A. Exclude fixed costs: Fixed costs are included; only variable costs change with activity levels.

B. Exclude outcome projections: Flexible budgets still use projected outcomes but adjust them based on actual performance.

C. Red flag for weak control: Flexible budgets enhance control by allowing real-time adjustments, making them a best practice rather than a red flag.

IIA GTAG on Financial Management: Covers budgeting methods, including flexible budgeting.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management: Encourages adaptive financial planning for effective risk management.

COSO ERM Framework: Recommends dynamic financial planning, including flexible budgeting.

Relevant IIA References:✅ Final Answer: Flexible budgets project data for different levels of activity (Option D).

Big data refers to extremely large and complex datasets that require advanced analytics to extract insights. Effective visualization is a crucial step in making big data analytics actionable.

Let’s analyze the options:

A. Big data is often structured.

Incorrect. Big data can be structured, semi-structured, or unstructured. Many sources of big data (e.g., social media, sensor data, emails) are unstructured, making analysis more challenging.

B. Big data analytic results often need to be visualized. ✅ (Correct Answer)

Correct. Due to its complexity, big data analytics results must often be visualized using dashboards, charts, or graphs to communicate insights effectively.

Examples of visualization tools include Tableau, Power BI, and Google Data Studio.

C. Big data is often generated slowly and is highly variable.

Incorrect. Big data is typically generated rapidly and continuously (e.g., social media posts, IoT sensors, financial transactions). This relates to the "velocity" characteristic of big data.

D. Big data comes from internal sources kept in data warehouses.

Incorrect. Big data comes from both internal and external sources, including social media, cloud applications, and sensors. Additionally, data warehouses store structured data, whereas big data is often unstructured and stored in data lakes.

IIA GTAG – Auditing Big Data Analytics – Explores best practices for analyzing and visualizing big data.

COSO ERM Framework – Technology & Data Risk – Discusses the need for big data governance and visualization.

ISO/IEC 27032 – Cybersecurity and Data Analytics – Covers big data security and interpretation.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management in Big Data Analytics – Focuses on internal auditors' role in overseeing data-driven decision-making.

IIA References:

The high-low method is a technique used in cost accounting to separate variable and fixed costs by analyzing the highest and lowest levels of activity. By computing the difference between the high and low levels of maintenance costs, the clerk determines the variable portion of maintenance costs.

High-Low Method Calculation:

Identify the highest and lowest activity levels and their corresponding costs.

Compute the change in cost (difference between high and low costs).

Compute the change in activity level (difference between high and low activity).

Divide change in cost by change in activity to determine the variable cost per unit.

Variable Costs Identified: The cost that changes with activity level is the variable maintenance cost.

Option A (Fixed maintenance costs): Fixed costs remain unchanged regardless of activity level, but the high-low method focuses on variable costs.

Option C (Mixed maintenance costs): Mixed costs include both fixed and variable components, but the high-low method isolates the variable portion.

Option D (Indirect maintenance costs): Indirect costs refer to overhead expenses, which may or may not be relevant in the high-low method analysis.

IIA’s Business Knowledge for Internal Auditing (CIA Exam Part 3 Syllabus) covers cost accounting concepts, including cost behavior analysis and methods like the high-low approach.

IIA’s Guide on Financial Management & Internal Control supports understanding cost analysis techniques for budgeting and financial planning.

Why Option B is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the most appropriate answer is B. Variable maintenance costs.

Residual income (RI) is a performance measure that considers both profits and the investment base by calculating the excess income generated over a required minimum return on investment (ROI).

(A) Residual income (Correct Answer):

Formula: Residual Income=Operating Income−(Required Rate of Return×Investment Base)\text{Residual Income} = \text{Operating Income} - (\text{Required Rate of Return} \times \text{Investment Base})Residual Income=Operating Income−(Required Rate of Return×Investment Base)

RI evaluates profitability after accounting for the cost of capital, making it a better measure of financial performance than net income alone.

It considers both profits (net operating income) and the investment base (capital employed).

(B) A flexible budget:

A flexible budget adjusts based on changes in activity levels but does not directly include investment base considerations.

(C) Variance analysis:

Variance analysis compares actual vs. budgeted performance but does not consider investment base.

(D) A contribution margin income statement by segment:

The contribution margin shows revenue minus variable costs but does not factor in the investment base.

IIA Practice Guide: Measuring Performance – Recognizes residual income as a key metric for evaluating divisional performance.

COSO ERM Framework – Performance Measurement Component – Emphasizes using metrics that account for both profitability and investment.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management – Highlights the importance of financial metrics in evaluating strategic objectives.

Analysis of Each Option:IIA References:Conclusion:Since Residual Income (RI) considers both profits and investment base, option (A) is the correct answer.

A Cold Site is a remote disaster recovery facility that provides physical space and basic utilities such as electricity, internet, and telecommunications but does not include pre-installed servers, networking equipment, or other IT infrastructure. It requires a longer recovery time since the organization must procure, install, and configure necessary hardware and software before resuming operations.

A. Frozen Site – This is not a recognized term in IT disaster recovery planning.

C. Warm Site – A warm site has some pre-installed hardware and infrastructure but requires additional setup before full operation.

D. Hot Site – A hot site is a fully functional duplicate of the original site, with real-time data replication, allowing for immediate recovery.

The IIA Global Technology Audit Guide (GTAG) 10: Business Continuity Management emphasizes that organizations should classify recovery sites based on risk tolerance and recovery time objectives (RTO).

The IIA’s International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) – Practice Advisory 2110-2 discusses IT continuity and disaster recovery as a critical element of internal audit assessments.

NIST Special Publication 800-34 (Contingency Planning Guide for Information Technology Systems) defines and categorizes disaster recovery sites, aligning with the cold site definition.

Explanation of the Other Options:IIA References & Best Practices:Thus, the correct answer is B. Cold Site.

Understanding Strategic Levels in an Organization:

Corporate-Level Strategy: Defines overall company direction, including mergers, acquisitions, and diversification.

Business-Level Strategy: Focuses on how the company competes in its industry (e.g., cost leadership, differentiation).

Functional-Level Strategy: Relates to specific departments (marketing, HR, IT) supporting business-level goals.

Why Option C (Business-Level Strategy) Is Correct?

The question "How does our organization compete?" directly relates to business-level strategy.

It focuses on competitive positioning within the industry, such as:

Cost leadership (competing on price)

Differentiation (unique product offerings)

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance requires auditors to evaluate strategic alignment with competitive positioning.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect?

Option A (Functional-Level Strategy):

Focuses on departmental decisions, not overall competition.

Option B (Corporate-Level Strategy):

Corporate strategy defines broad company direction, not specific competition strategies.

Option D (Department-Level Strategy):

Similar to functional strategy, it does not define how the company competes in the industry.

Business-level strategy answers "How does our organization compete?" by defining industry-specific competitive approaches.

IIA Standard 2110 supports governance over strategic positioning.

Final Justification:IIA References:

IPPF Standard 2110 – Governance (Strategic Planning & Competitive Advantage)

Porter’s Competitive Strategy Framework

COSO ERM – Strategic Risk Management