The best recommendation is B because the slow query filters on FleetId and returns LastUpdatedUtc , EngineStatus , and BatteryHealth . A nonclustered index with FleetId as the key column allows the optimizer to perform an index seek instead of a clustered index scan, and including the other selected columns makes the index covering , which reduces extra lookups and I/O. Microsoft’s SQL Server indexing guidance states that a nonclustered index with included columns can significantly improve performance when all query columns are available in the index, because the optimizer can satisfy the query directly from the index.

The query is:

SELECT VehicleId, LastUpdatedUtc, EngineStatus, BatteryHealth

FROM dbo.VehicleHealthSummary

WHERE FleetId = @FleetId

ORDER BY LastUpdatedUtc DESC;

Among the given choices, FleetId is the most important search argument because it appears in the WHERE predicate. Microsoft’s index design guidance recommends putting columns used for searching in the key and using nonkey included columns to cover the rest of the query efficiently.

Why the other options are weaker:

A is not appropriate because changing the clustered index to LastUpdatedUtc would not target the main filter predicate on FleetId, and a table can have only one clustered index.

C makes LastUpdatedUtc the key, which is poor for a query whose primary filter is FleetId.

D is not the right answer here because the query requirement does not specify only recent rows, and filtered indexes are meant for a well-defined subset; this option also uses a time-based expression that is not aligned to the stated query pattern.

Strictly speaking, the most optimal design for both filtering and ordering would usually be a composite key like (FleetId, LastUpdatedUtc), but since that is not one of the available options, B is the correct exam answer.