Pass the IIA CIA IIA-CIA-Part3 Questions and answers with CertsForce

To assess the success of a piloted data analytics model in identifying anomalies in vendor payments and potential fraud, the most appropriate criterion is the accuracy of the model in identifying true positives—cases flagged as anomalies that were later confirmed as valid fraud risks.

Effectiveness of the Model: The primary goal of the model is to enhance the internal audit activity’s ability to detect fraudulent transactions. The best way to measure success is to analyze how many flagged transactions were confirmed as fraudulent or erroneous.

Reduction of False Positives and False Negatives: A model that generates too many false positives (incorrectly flagged transactions) can lead to inefficiencies, while too many false negatives (missed fraudulent cases) can reduce the effectiveness of fraud detection.

Alignment with Internal Audit Standards: According to IIA Standard 1220 - Due Professional Care, internal auditors must apply appropriate tools and techniques (such as data analytics) to enhance audit effectiveness. The model's success should be assessed based on its ability to provide reliable, actionable insights.

IIA Practice Guide on Data Analytics: Recommends assessing the predictive accuracy of models by comparing flagged transactions against actual outcomes.

B. The development and maintenance costs associated with the model (Incorrect)

While cost is a consideration, it does not directly assess the effectiveness of the model in detecting fraud.

High costs may indicate inefficiency, but they do not determine whether the model is accurately identifying fraudulent transactions.

IIA Standard 2100 - Nature of Work emphasizes that internal audit activities must contribute to the improvement of governance, risk management, and control, which requires a focus on results rather than just cost.

C. The feedback of auditors involved with developing the model (Incorrect)

Feedback is useful but subjective. The ultimate test of success is not auditor perception but whether the model correctly identifies fraudulent or anomalous transactions.

IIA Practice Guide: Auditing Data Analytics suggests that while stakeholder feedback is valuable, empirical validation (accuracy of flagged cases) should be the primary success measure.

D. The number of criminal investigations initiated based on the outcomes of the model (Incorrect)

While fraud detection can lead to investigations, the number of investigations is not necessarily an accurate measure of model success.

Some flagged cases may not lead to criminal investigations due to materiality, lack of sufficient evidence, or management decisions.

According to IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management, internal auditors must evaluate fraud risk management effectiveness, which includes detecting and preventing fraud, not just the legal consequences.

Explanation of Answer Choice A (Correct Answer):Explanation of Incorrect Answers:Conclusion:The best success criterion for the piloted data analytics model is the percentage of cases flagged by the model and confirmed as positives (Option A), as it directly measures the model's effectiveness in detecting actual fraud cases.

IIA References:

IIA Standard 1220 - Due Professional Care

IIA Standard 2100 - Nature of Work

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management

IIA Practice Guide: Auditing Data Analytics

A firewall is a security control mechanism designed to prevent unauthorized access to or from a private network. It monitors and filters incoming and outgoing network traffic based on predefined security rules.

Definition of Control Types:

Preventive Control: Stops an undesirable event from occurring.

Detective Control: Identifies and records events after they have happened.

Corrective Control: Takes action to correct an issue after it has been detected.

Discretionary Control: Provides access control based on user discretion.

Why a Firewall is a Preventive Control:

Firewalls block unauthorized access to protect networks before a security breach can occur.

They enforce security policies in real-time, preventing cyber threats such as malware, intrusions, and unauthorized data access.

As per IIA GTAG (Global Technology Audit Guide) on Information Security, firewalls are categorized as preventive controls because they proactively mitigate threats before they materialize.

Why Not Other Options?

A. Corrective: Firewalls do not correct security breaches; they prevent them.

B. Detective: Firewalls do not just detect threats but actively block them.

D. Discretionary: Firewalls operate based on preset security rules rather than user discretion.

IIA GTAG – Information Security

IIA Standard 2110 – IT Governance & Risk Management

Step-by-Step Justification:IIA References:Thus, the correct and verified answer is C. Preventive.

Understanding Outsourcing:

Outsourcing refers to contracting business processes, functions, or expertise to an external service provider.

Companies use outsourcing to reduce costs, access specialized skills, and improve efficiency.

Why Option B (Contracting Functions or Knowledge-Related Work with an External Provider) Is Correct?

Outsourcing involves delegating specific business functions (e.g., IT support, payroll, customer service) to external specialists.

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance supports evaluating outsourcing risks and effectiveness.

ISO 37500 – Outsourcing Management Framework emphasizes knowledge-based work outsourcing for expertise gains.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect?

Option A (Foreign service providers for cost savings):

While some outsourcing involves foreign providers, outsourcing is not limited to offshoring.

Option C (Internal service provider):

Internal service providers do not involve outsourcing, as the work remains within the company.

Option D (External + internal provider collaboration):

This describes co-sourcing, not pure outsourcing.

Outsourcing involves contracting business functions to an external provider, making option B correct.

IIA Standard 2110 supports governance over outsourcing decisions and risk management.

Final Justification:IIA References:

IPPF Standard 2110 – Governance (Outsourcing & Vendor Risk Management)

ISO 37500 – Outsourcing Management Framework

COSO ERM – Third-Party Risk Management in Outsourcing

The best method of compensation to align senior management incentives with the long-term health of the organization is stock options. Stock options encourage executives to focus on sustained growth and profitability rather than short-term gains, ensuring that their interests align with those of shareholders and stakeholders.

Long-Term Value Creation:

Stock options reward executives only if the company’s stock price appreciates over time.

This encourages leadership to focus on long-term profitability, operational efficiency, and sustainability.

Alignment with Shareholder Interests:

If the company performs well, stock prices rise, benefiting both shareholders and executives.

Poor decision-making that harms long-term value results in devalued stock options, discouraging risky short-term strategies.

Retention of Key Executives:

Stock options typically have a vesting period (e.g., 3-5 years), which helps retain top management and ensures commitment to long-term objectives.

Risk Management Considerations:

Unlike cash bonuses or short-term commissions, stock options require executives to consider risks and ethical decision-making over an extended period.

This supports the governance principles outlined by IIA’s International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing (IPPF) – Standard 2110 (Governance), which emphasizes aligning incentives with risk tolerance and long-term objectives.

A. Commissions: These are typically tied to short-term sales performance rather than long-term strategic success.

C. Gain-sharing bonuses: These provide short-term financial rewards based on operational performance but do not incentivize sustained value creation.

D. Allowances: Fixed allowances do not fluctuate based on company performance and do not drive long-term strategic focus.

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance: Ensures that management incentives align with the organization's mission and risk tolerance.

IIA Practice Guide: Evaluating Corporate Governance: Emphasizes long-term incentive structures such as stock options to promote sustainable decision-making.

COSO Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) Framework: Highlights how executive compensation should support long-term organizational strategy.

Step-by-Step Justification:Why Not the Other Options?IIA References:

Data and system backups are a critical part of business continuity and disaster recovery (BC/DR) strategies, ensuring that organizations can restore data and systems to a prior state in the event of system failure, cyberattacks, or disasters.

Primary Purpose of Backup Systems:

The core objective of data and systems backup is to restore data and systems to a previous point in time in case of an unexpected incident.

According to IIA GTAG on Business Continuity Management, backups enable organizations to recover lost, corrupted, or compromised data from an earlier state.

Why Not Other Options?

A. To restore all data and systems immediately after the occurrence of an incident:

This is a misconception because restoration times depend on the Recovery Time Objective (RTO) and the complexity of the incident.

B. To set the maximum allowable downtime to restore systems and data after the occurrence of an incident:

This describes RTO, which is part of business continuity planning but not the primary purpose of backups.

C. To set the point in time to which systems and data must be recovered after the occurrence of an incident:

This describes the Recovery Point Objective (RPO), which determines the acceptable amount of data loss but does not define the main goal of backups.

IIA GTAG – Business Continuity Management

IIA Practice Guide: Auditing Business Continuity and Disaster Recovery

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management and IT Controls

Step-by-Step Justification:IIA References:Thus, the correct and verified answer is D. To restore data and systems to a previous point in time after the occurrence of an incident

Duplicate testing is an analytical technique used to detect fraudulent payments, errors, or inefficiencies by identifying repeated transactions within financial records. In this case, an internal auditor would use duplicate testing to ensure that employees are not receiving fraudulent invoice payments by verifying that no invoice has been paid multiple times.

Detecting Duplicate Payments: Fraudulent employees may submit the same invoice multiple times with slight modifications to avoid detection. Duplicate testing helps find identical or similar transactions.

Identifying Unusual Patterns: By analyzing payment records, auditors can detect repeat payments to the same vendor, same invoice number, or similar amounts within a short time frame.

Aligns with Fraud Prevention Practices: As per IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management, internal auditors must identify and assess fraud risks, including duplicate invoice payments.

Supports Data Analytics in Auditing: IIA GTAG (Global Technology Audit Guide) 16 - Data Analysis Techniques recommends using duplicate testing to identify fraud, control weaknesses, and errors in financial transactions.

A. Perform gap testing: Gap testing is used to identify missing data or transactions in a sequence (e.g., missing invoice numbers), but it does not specifically target duplicate or fraudulent payments.

B. Join different data sources: This method is useful for cross-checking information across multiple databases, but it is not directly related to identifying duplicate invoice payments.

D. Calculate statistical parameters: Statistical analysis provides summary insights about data (e.g., mean, median), but it does not specifically detect duplicate payments.

IIA Standard 2120 - Risk Management: Internal auditors must evaluate fraud risks, including duplicate payments.

IIA Standard 1220 - Due Professional Care: Requires auditors to apply appropriate data analytics techniques.

IIA GTAG 16 - Data Analysis Techniques: Recommends duplicate testing as an effective fraud detection method.

Key Reasons Why Option C is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the correct answer is C. Perform duplicate testing.

A partnership is a business structure where two or more individuals share ownership, responsibilities, and profits or losses. The accounting treatment of a partnership follows GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles) and IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards).

Let’s analyze each option:

A. The initial investment of each partner should be recorded at book value.

Incorrect. The initial investment is recorded at fair market value (FMV) at the time of contribution, not at book value. This ensures that all assets contributed by partners reflect their current worth.

B. The ownership ratio identifies the basis for dividing net income and net loss. ✅ (Correct Answer)

Correct. A partnership agreement typically specifies profit and loss-sharing ratios based on ownership percentages. If no agreement exists, profits and losses are divided equally among partners.

Example: If Partner A owns 60% and Partner B owns 40%, they will split net income or loss in this ratio.

C. A partner's capital only changes due to net income or net loss.

Incorrect. A partner’s capital account changes due to additional investments, withdrawals, revaluations of assets, and profit/loss allocations.

D. The basis for sharing net income or net losses must be fixed.

Incorrect. Partners can change the allocation method over time through a revised partnership agreement. It is not required to remain fixed.

IIA Practice Guide – Assessing Financial Statement Risk – Covers partnership accounting risks.

GAAP & IFRS – Partnership Accounting Standards – Explain the treatment of capital accounts and income distribution.

COSO Internal Control Framework – Financial Reporting Risk – Discusses financial treatment of equity structures.

IIA Standard 2120 – Risk Management – Highlights financial statement risks, including partnerships.

IIA References:

According to IIA guidance on IT project success, successful IT projects focus on delivering critical, high-value features that support business objectives rather than overloading with unnecessary features.

Let’s analyze each option:

A. Streamlined decision-making, rather than building consensus among users.

Incorrect. While efficient decision-making is important, user consensus is crucial to IT project success, as user adoption affects the outcome. Ignoring user feedback can lead to project failure.

B. Consideration of the facts, rather than consideration of the emotions displayed by project stakeholders.

Incorrect. Stakeholder emotions and concerns must be managed properly. Ignoring stakeholder engagement can lead to resistance and project failure.

C. Focus on flexibility and adaptability, rather than use of a formal methodology.

Incorrect. IT projects must follow structured methodologies (Agile, Waterfall, etc.). A lack of formal methodology increases project risks.

D. Inclusion of critical features, rather than inclusion of an array of supplementary features. ✅ (Correct Answer)

Correct. IT projects should focus on delivering core, high-impact features that align with business needs. Adding too many non-essential features increases costs, complexity, and delays.

IIA GTAG (Global Technology Audit Guide) – Auditing IT Projects – Focuses on IT project governance and success factors.

COBIT Framework – IT Governance and Management – Emphasizes prioritization of key project features.

ISO/IEC 27001 – IT Risk Management – Discusses project management best practices.

IIA Standard 2110 – Governance – Covers IT project oversight and stakeholder management.

IIA References:Would you like me to verify more questions? ????

Understanding The IIA’s Three Lines Model:

The Three Lines Model defines responsibilities for risk management and control across different organizational functions:

First Line: Operational management (owns and manages risks).

Second Line: Risk and compliance functions (monitors and facilitates risk management).

Third Line: Internal audit (provides independent assurance).

Why Third-Party and Supplier Assessments Are Shared Across All Three Lines:

First Line (Operational Teams & IT Security): Ensures that vendors comply with security standards.

Second Line (Risk & Compliance Teams): Conducts due diligence and ensures compliance with cybersecurity regulations.

Third Line (Internal Audit): Independently evaluates supplier risk management processes.

Why Other Options Are Less Relevant:

B. Recruitment and retention of certified IT talent – Primarily a first-line management responsibility (HR and IT departments).

C. Classification of data and design of access privileges – Typically a first-line IT security function, with oversight from the second line.

D. Creation and maintenance of secure network configurations – Falls under first-line IT operations with oversight but not shared by all three lines.

IIA’s Three Lines Model (2020 Update): Emphasizes shared responsibilities in areas like third-party risk.

IIA Practice Guide on Third-Party Risk Management: Internal audit must assess supplier security and compliance.

COSO ERM Framework: Highlights vendor risk management as a cross-functional responsibility.

Relevant IIA References:✅ Final Answer: Assessments of third parties and suppliers (Option A).

A turnkey contract is a type of procurement agreement where the contractor is responsible for the entire project from planning and design to construction and delivery, ensuring that the organization receives a fully operational facility. In this case, the organization wants to transfer all risks to the builder, making a turnkey contract the most appropriate choice.

Full Risk Transfer: The contractor assumes all project risks, including design flaws, cost overruns, and delays.

Single-Point Responsibility: The builder is accountable for all aspects of the project until it is fully operational.

Minimal Client Involvement: The client does not have to manage the project’s complexities.

Option A (Cost-plus contract): This contract type does not transfer all risk to the builder; instead, the client bears some risk as they pay for actual costs plus a profit margin.

Option C (Service contract): Service contracts typically cover specific services (e.g., maintenance, consulting), not full construction projects.

Option D (Solutions contract): A solutions contract generally refers to software or technology solutions, not physical facility construction.

IIA’s Practice Guide on Contract Management and Risk Transfer: Highlights turnkey contracts as a method to shift project risks to third parties.

IIA’s Business Knowledge for Internal Auditing (CIA Exam Part 3 Syllabus): Covers procurement and contract types, emphasizing risk transfer mechanisms.

Why Option B is Correct:Why Other Options Are Incorrect:IIA References:Thus, the most appropriate answer is B. Turnkey contract.