The correct answers are A and C . In the Evaluation Phase , the VM team moves from broad creative idea generation into structured judgment. SAVE’s VM guidance identifies the Evaluation Phase as the point where ideas from the Creative Phase are synthesized, sorted, rated, ranked, and selected for development using previously established evaluation criteria. It also identifies fine filter activity as detailed evaluation, not a quick vote or informal reaction. ( courses.washington.edu )

A SWOT analysis for each idea is a fine filter action because it examines strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats in a structured way. This supports deeper evaluation of feasibility, risk, benefits, constraints, and implementation exposure. Aligning each idea with the subject study goals is also correct because fine filtering must test whether an idea supports the agreed VM study objectives, user/customer needs, performance expectations, and value targets.

Option B is incorrect because feedback without discussion is closer to simple screening and does not represent detailed evaluation. Option D is too narrow because VM does not rank ideas only by estimated cost; value requires consideration of function, performance, quality, risk, time, and overall benefit.

References/topics: Evaluation Phase; Fine Filter; Evaluation Criteria; Idea Screening; VM Study Goals.