The best option for investigating the tradeoffs between different parameter combinations is to create an experiment in Vertex AI Experiments, create a Vertex AI pipeline with a custom model training job as part of the pipeline, configure the pipeline’s parameters to include those you are investigating, and submit multiple runs to the same experiment using different values for the parameters. This option allows you to leverage the power and flexibility of Google Cloud to compare the pipeline performance of the different parameter combinations measured in F1 score, time to train, and model complexity. Vertex AI Experiments is a service that can track and compare the results of multiple machine learning runs. Vertex AI Experiments can record the metrics, parameters, and artifacts of each run, and display them in a dashboard for easy visualization and analysis. Vertex AI Experiments can also help users optimize the hyperparameters of their models by using different search algorithms, such as grid search, random search, or Bayesian optimization1. Vertex AI Pipelines is a service that can orchestrate machine learning workflows using Vertex AI. Vertex AI Pipelines can run preprocessing and training steps on custom Docker images, and evaluate, deploy, and monitor the machine learning model. A custom model training job is a type of pipeline step that can train a custom model by using a user-provided script or container. A custom model training job can accept pipeline parameters as inputs, which can be used to control the training logic or data source. By creating an experiment in Vertex AI Experiments, creating a Vertex AI pipeline with a custom model training job as part of the pipeline, configuring the pipeline’s parameters to include those you are investigating, and submitting multiple runs to the same experiment using different values for the parameters, you can create a reproducible and trackable approach to investigate the tradeoffs between different parameter combinations.

The other options are not as good as option D, for the following reasons:

Option A: Using BigQuery ML to create a boosted tree regressor and use the hyperparameter tuning capability, configuring the hyperparameter syntax to select different input datasets, max tree depths, and optimizer learning rates, and choosing the grid search option would not be able to handle different input datasets as a hyperparameter, and would not be as flexible and scalable as using Vertex AI Experiments and Vertex AI Pipelines. BigQuery ML is a service that can create and train machine learning models by using SQL queries on BigQuery. BigQuery ML can perform hyperparameter tuning by using the ML.FORECAST or ML.PREDICT functions, and specifying the hyperparameters option. BigQuery ML can also use different search algorithms, such as grid search, random search, or Bayesian optimization, to find the optimal hyperparameters. However, BigQuery ML can only tune the hyperparameters that are related to the model architecture or training process, such as max tree depth or learning rate. BigQuery ML cannot tune the hyperparameters that are related to the data source, such as input dataset. Moreover, BigQuery ML is not designed to work with Vertex AI Experiments or Vertex AI Pipelines, which can provide more features and flexibility for tracking and orchestrating machine learning workflows2.

Option B: Creating a Vertex AI pipeline with a custom model training job as part of the pipeline, configuring the pipeline’s parameters to include those you are investigating, and using the Bayesian optimization method with F1 score as the target to maximize in the custom training step would not be able to track and compare the results of multiple runs, and would require more skills and steps than using Vertex AI Experiments and Vertex AI Pipelines. Vertex AI Pipelines is a service that can orchestrate machine learning workflows using Vertex AI. Vertex AI Pipelines can run preprocessing and training steps on custom Docker images, and evaluate, deploy, and monitor the machine learning model. A custom model training job is a type of pipeline step that can train a custom model by using a user-provided script or container. A custom model training job can accept pipeline parameters as inputs, which can be used to control the training logic or data source. However, using the Bayesian optimization method with F1 score as the target to maximize in the custom training step would require writing code, implementing the optimization algorithm, and defining the objective function. Moreover, this option would not be able to track and compare the results of multiple runs, as Vertex AI Pipelines does not have a built-in feature for recording and displaying the metrics, parameters, and artifacts of each run3.

Option C: Creating a Vertex AI Workbench notebook for each of the different input datasets, running different local training jobs with different combinations of the max tree depth and optimizer learning rate parameters, and appending the results to a BigQuery table would not be able to track and compare the results of multiple runs on the same platform, and would require more skills and steps than using Vertex AI Experiments and Vertex AI Pipelines. Vertex AI Workbench is a service that provides an integrated development environment for data science and machine learning. Vertex AI Workbench allows users to create and run Jupyter notebooks on Google Cloud, and access various tools and libraries for data analysis and machine learning. However, creating a Vertex AI Workbench notebook for each of the different input datasets, running different local training jobs with different combinations of the max tree depth and optimizer learning rate parameters, and appending the results to a BigQuery table would require creating multiple notebooks, writing code, setting up local environments, connecting to BigQuery, loading and preprocessing the data, training and evaluating the model, and writing the results to a BigQuery table. Moreover, this option would not be able to track and compare the results of multiple runs on the same platform, as BigQuery is a separate service from Vertex AI Workbench, and does not have a dashboard for visualizing and analyzing the metrics, parameters, and artifacts of each run4.

References:

Preparing for Google Cloud Certification: Machine Learning Engineer, Course 3: Production ML Systems, Week 3: MLOps

Google Cloud Professional Machine Learning Engineer Exam Guide, Section 1: Architecting low-code ML solutions, 1.1 Developing ML models by using BigQuery ML

Official Google Cloud Certified Professional Machine Learning Engineer Study Guide, Chapter 3: Data Engineering for ML, Section 3.2: BigQuery for ML

Vertex AI Experiments

Vertex AI Pipelines

BigQuery ML

Vertex AI Workbench