The issue described in the question, where incoming traffic seems to favor one EC2 instance, is often caused by session affinity (also known as sticky sessions) being enabled on the Application Load Balancer (ALB). When session affinity is enabled, the ALB routes requests from the same client to the same EC2 instance. This can cause an imbalance in traffic distribution, leading to performance bottlenecks on certain instances while others remain underutilized.

To resolve this issue, disabling session affinity ensures that the ALB distributes incoming traffic evenly across all EC2 instances, allowing better load distribution and reducing latency. The ALB will rely on its round-robin or least outstanding requests algorithm (depending on the configuration) to distribute traffic more evenly across instances.

Option B (Network Load Balancer): The NLB is designed for Layer 4 (TCP) traffic and low latency use cases, but it is not needed here as the problem is with load balancing logic at the application layer (Layer 7). The ALB is more appropriate for HTTP/HTTPS traffic.

Option C (Increase EC2 Instances): Adding more EC2 instances does not solve the root issue of uneven traffic distribution.

Option D (Health Check Frequency): Adjusting health check frequency won't address the imbalance caused by session affinity.

AWS References:

Application Load Balancer Sticky Sessions