AWS recommends Auto Scaling with dynamic scaling policies to handle unpredictable workload spikes. Target tracking scaling policies automatically adjust capacity based on defined metrics such as average CPU utilization or request count per target. This approach ensures applications maintain responsiveness without overprovisioning. Scheduled scaling (options B and C) is only effective when traffic patterns are predictable, which is not the case here. Reserved Instances or Spot Instances also do not address sudden demand changes effectively. Replacing the ALB with an NLB (D) does not solve latency caused by EC2 instance capacity. Therefore, using EC2 instances in an Auto Scaling group with a target tracking scaling policy is the most effective and cost-efficient solution for unpredictable, short-lived traffic spikes.