The requirement involves automating an action during a workflow transition (copying a comment entered on a transition screen to the work log description when closing issues). As correctly noted, this type of automation is typically handled by aworkflow post function, which executes actions after a transition is completed. However, the provided options do not include "workflow post function." Among the options,Workflow condition(Option D) is the closest, as it points to the general area of workflow configuration where post functions are also managed, despite being technically inaccurate since conditions and post functions serve different purposes. Let’s analyze this in detail.
Explanation of the Correct Approach (Workflow Post Function):
Aworkflow post functionis the appropriate mechanism to copy the comment entered on the transition screen to the work log description during theClose Issuetransition. Post functions are executed automatically after a transition completes, and they can manipulate issue data, such as copying field values. However, Jira’s out-of-the-box post functions (e.g.,Copy Value From Other Field) may not directly support copying a transition screen comment to a work log description, as the comment field on a transition screen is transient and not stored as a standard issuefield until the transition is complete. This may require a custom post function or a third-party app (e.g., ScriptRunner) to script the behavior.
Alternatively, aJira automation rulecould achieve this by triggering on theIssue Transitionedevent (to the Closed status) and copying the latest comment to the work log description, but automation rules are configured separately and not part of the workflow editor.
Exact Extract from Documentation:
Configure workflow post functions
Post functions are executed after a transition is completed and can perform actions like updating fields or copying data.
To configure:
Go toSettings > Issues > Workflows.
Edit the workflow and select theClose Issuetransition.
Add a post function (e.g.,Copy Value From Other Fieldor a scripted post function via an app).Note: Copying a transition screen comment to a work log description may require a custom script or third-party app, as standard post functions do not directly support this.(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Configure advanced work item workflows")
Why This Fits the Requirement: A post function on theClose Issuetransition can automate the copying of the comment to the work log description, aligning with the requirement for an action during a workflow transition.
Analysis of the Options and Selection of Option D:
The options provided do not include "workflow post function," which is the precise configuration area. However, let’s evaluate each option:
Field configuration (Option A):
Field configurationscontrol whether fields are required, optional, or hidden for specific issue types. They do not handle automation or copying data between fields during transitions.
Extract from Documentation:
Field configurations manage field behavior (required, hidden), not field value copying or automation.
(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Configure field settings")
Global time tracking settings manage time tracking behavior, not field interactions or automation.
(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Configure time tracking in Jira Cloud")
Issue layout (Option C):
Issue layoutsdetermine field visibility and arrangement in the issue view (e.g., which fields are shown or hidden). They do not manage automation or data copying during transitions.
Extract from Documentation:
Issue layouts control field display in the issue view, not field value copying or automation.
(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Configure issue layouts in Jira Cloud")
Conditions restrict transition access, while post functions perform actions like updating fields. Both are configured in the workflow editor under the transition settings.
(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Configure advanced work item workflows")
Global permissions manage system access, not field automation or workflow actions.
(Source: Atlassian Support Documentation, "Manage global permissions")
Why Option D is Selected: WhileWorkflow conditionis technically incorrect (as conditions do not copy data), it points to the workflow configuration area where the correct solution—apost function—is implemented. In the absence of a "workflow post function" option, Option D is the closest match, likely due to a wording error in the question. The user’s analysis aligns with this interpretation, recognizing that the solution lies within the workflow editor, specifically with post functions.
Additional Notes:
Steps to Configure a Post Function:
Go toSettings > Issues > Workflows(requires Jira administrator privileges).
Edit the workflow used by the project and select theClose Issuetransition.
Add a post function to copy the transition screen comment to the work log description (this may require a custom script or third-party app like ScriptRunner, as standard post functions do not directly support this).
Alternative with Automation Rule:
Go toProject settings > Automation(orSettings > System > Automation rulesfor global rules).
Create a rule with the triggerIssue Transitioned(to Closed status).
Add a condition to check for a new comment (if needed).
Add an action to edit the work log and copy the latest comment to the work log description (may require scripting or app support).
The question’s options suggest a possible oversight in not including "workflow post function." However, interpretingWorkflow conditionas a reference to the broader workflow configuration area (where post functions are managed) makes it the most reasonable choice.
[:, Atlassian Support Documentation:Configure advanced work item workflows, Atlassian Support Documentation:Automate your Jira Cloud instance, Atlassian Support Documentation:Configure field settings, Atlassian Support Documentation:Configure time tracking in Jira Cloud, Atlassian Support Documentation:Configure issue layouts in Jira Cloud, Atlassian Support Documentation:Manage global permissions, , ]
Submit