Within Health Care Risk Management frameworks supported by ASHRM and the American Hospital Association Certification Center, effective incident reporting systems depend heavily on organizational culture. When underreporting is identified, the most appropriate first step is to evaluate whether a just culture exists and whether staff perceive reporting as safe, nonpunitive, and constructive. Fear of retaliation, lack of feedback, time constraints, and unclear reporting procedures are common barriers that suppress reporting rates.

A punitive response such as disciplining staff may further discourage transparency and undermine patient safety initiatives. Conducting a root cause analysis may be appropriate if a specific adverse event occurred, but in this scenario the systemic issue is underreporting itself, which is primarily cultural and operational in nature. Immediate notification of the liability insurer would not address the underlying safety system weakness.

Health care operations objectives emphasize creating a culture of safety that encourages voluntary reporting, learning, and system improvement. By assessing and strengthening reporting culture, leadership can improve data accuracy, enhance early risk identification, and support proactive patient safety management.