Peer review files are confidential and protected by state and federal laws to ensure privacy and encourage candid evaluation. Sharing such files with unauthorized individuals violates confidentiality and legal protections (The Joint Commission, Peer Review Confidentiality, 2024; NAHQ, Ethics in Quality, 2024). The correct action is to deny the request and report it to leadership or risk management to ensure proper handling. Obtaining permission (Option D) is generally not sufficient without formal processes. Partial disclosure (Option B) or full release (Option C) is inappropriate and may expose the organization to liability. Proper stewardship of peer review information protects quality improvement efforts and provider privacy.