As per the AWS Cloud Operations and Content Delivery documentation, CloudFront determines cache behavior by evaluating both origin headers (e.g., Cache-Control and Expires) and distribution-level TTL settings.

When Cache-Control max-age conflicts with the Maximum TTL configured in CloudFront, the shorter TTL value takes precedence. This results in CloudFront caching content for only 5 minutes instead of 1 hour, despite the origin headers suggesting a longer duration.

AWS documentation explicitly states: “When both origin cache headers and CloudFront TTL settings are defined, CloudFront uses the most restrictive caching period.” This mismatch causes the perceived performance drop, as CloudFront frequently revalidates content.

Therefore, Option D is correct — cache-duration settings conflict with each other, leading to unexpected caching behavior.