To ensure traffic from a VPC to AWS KMS stays on the AWS network and does not use public endpoints, you should use aninterface VPC endpoint (AWS PrivateLink) for KMS. Creating aVPC endpoint for KMS with private DNS enabled(Option C) causes standard KMS DNS names (for example, kms. < region > .amazonaws.com) to resolve to theprivateendpoint IPs inside the VPC, routing requests over the AWS private network rather than through the internet. This is the core networking control that satisfies “no public service endpoints.”

To enforce that only calls that come through the intended VPC endpoint can use the key, add an authorization guardrail in theKMS key policyusing the aws:sourceVpce condition (Option A). This ensures that even if a principal has credentials, KMS will deny usage unless the request is made via the specified VPC endpoint, preventing accidental or malicious use over public paths.

Option B is neither necessary nor sufficient: removing an internet gateway does not prevent all public endpoint use (NAT, other egress paths, or other VPCs could still be involved) and can break workloads. Option D is unrelated to runtime KMS API traffic. Option E is weaker because SourceIp checks can be bypassed via other AWS network paths and does not guarantee PrivateLink usage the way sourceVpce does.