The EC2 instances are in private subnets with no public internet access, yet the CloudWatch agent must publish metrics to Amazon CloudWatch. To send metrics, the instances need: (1) network connectivity to CloudWatch APIs, and (2) IAM permissions that allow the agent to publish metrics and logs.

The most secure approach is to avoid opening outbound internet access via a NAT gateway (which increases the network attack surface) and instead use AWS PrivateLink through a VPC interface endpoint for CloudWatch. An interface endpoint provides private connectivity from the VPC to CloudWatch without traversing the public internet.

On the permissions side, AWS provides the managed IAM policy CloudWatchAgentServerPolicy, which is intended for the CloudWatch agent running on servers to publish metrics/logs. Attaching this policy to the EC2 instance profile role provides the needed permissions while keeping scope appropriate (unlike an admin policy).

Why the other options are not best:

A uses CloudWatchAgentAdminPolicy (broader permissions than needed) and a NAT gateway (public internet path). That is not “most secure.”

B is irrelevant here because the agent is already installed and running; the issue is publishing connectivity/permissions.

D grants read-only access, which cannot publish metrics, so it cannot fix the issue.

Therefore, attach CloudWatchAgentServerPolicy to the instance role and create a VPC interface endpoint for CloudWatch.