“Encryption in transit” for S3 means requiring requests to use HTTPS (TLS) rather than HTTP. AWS provides a standard policy condition key, aws:SecureTransport, that evaluates to true when the request is made over SSL/TLS and false when it is not. To enforce TLS for all cross-account GetObject requests, the most reliable control point is the S3 bucket resource-based policy, because the bucket is the resource being accessed and the bucket owner can enforce conditions regardless of which external account is calling.

Option A is the established pattern: add an explicit Deny statement in the bucket policy that denies all S3 actions (or at least s3:GetObject) when aws:SecureTransport is false. An explicit deny overrides any allows, ensuring that even if another account’s IAM policy allows access, the request will still be blocked if it is not using HTTPS.

Option B is backwards because it would allow insecure transport rather than deny it.

Option C is weaker because you cannot reliably enforce policies in other accounts (and principals could change roles or permissions). The bucket owner should enforce transport security at the bucket level.

Option D is not the right layer: the KMS key policy controls key usage, but the S3 GetObject transport requirement is best enforced by the S3 bucket policy. Also, S3 access can be denied before KMS is even involved.

Therefore, enforce HTTPS by adding a bucket policy Deny when aws:SecureTransport is false.